
The first in a series of illustrated truths gathered over 14 years – an entirely honest and personal project.
Be it a couple of pounds or a whole half stone, (no joke) pitching is a tough old task on your body and mind.
The Pitch
Ain’t it the truth – that golden goose of opportunity within our industry to win a new client – the pressure is on, it’s a competition after all and the responsibility is on your shoulders to bring home the creative and financial bacon.
Pitching is a tough and bloody expensive deal – businesses are asked to spend time, expensive resource and often give away creative notions up front for little or no money at all – with no guaranteed work at the end of it. Competition can be fierce – remember hearing about the client who asked a total of 14 agencies to pitch for his restaurant rebrand?
Then there are the sharks who invite pitches only to hustle the free ideas to use freely further down the line thinking you don’t suspect that the design looks strikingly similar to something that you presented yourself 6 months ago. That’s just shoplifting. Have some respect.
A survey by Creativebrief discovered that respondents were largely in agreement that the traditional pitch process was no longer “fit for purpose” in the current environment – with 61% of brands and 93% of agencies wanting to see change. (1)
The debate about pitching continues to rumble – many agencies continuing to gather mutual support from each other that this work should be remunerated for, with some refusing outright to partake. A reported 82% of agencies agreed that they should be prepared to refuse to pitch for an account to encourage the process to change and modernise. (2)
Yet making the bold move to turn down a possible lead or prospective client just isn’t feasible or in the DNA of some traditionalists.
Though exciting and always an amazing feeling when you win (thankfully I’ve won more than lost) pitch-life is perceived from the outside in high esteem – glamorous almost, (we’ve got Mad Men to thank for that) and it is to degree it is. It’s great to propose a new way of thinking and taking a challenge square on and presenting the solution is always a huge buzz.
The Ugly Truth
The flip side of the cool exterior agency glamour can be somewhat different. Often short windows to produce the ‘silver bullet’ idea, soak up years’ worth of your client’s brand heritage within days, research the market and competitors, plan strategically, ensure you have the facts to back it up, stress test it and polish the creative to perfection – is all time and mentally intensive. It takes a lot of effort and years of honing your skillset to manage the process with a team all whilst keeping a veneer of cool, calm, and collected direction about you.
Long days blend seamlessly into nights working like a b’iatch shackled to a machine with all the good intentions of clean eating only to be overtaken by Deliveroo, fizzy drinks, and quick sugar hits (hello Haribo).
Sitting around drinking whiskey moodily like Don Draper isn’t how it goes down. (Correction. It does – I’ve seen it in all its glory but it tends to be the moody old-school types.)
There are the times you may have raided the agency Friday beers fridge by Wednesday with a fellow pitch-inmate and had a fair few laughs but in reality it’s not as carefree.
You haven’t taken a shower that’s lasted more than 3 minutes over the last week, you’ve slept poorly only to have your dreams permeated by your ongoing anxiety and your hair now resembles a plastic LEGO character’s clip-on ‘do. Let’s face it – you’re juggling at mental capacity now.
It’s a roller-coaster of emotions, however long you’ve been in the game. There are the confidence and lightbulb moments “we’ve got this bloody nailed here lads” to the lower points that lead you to question your entire existence and success in the creative sector at all.
The energy and expectation to be work-ready and deliver with an air of effortless grace, all whilst representing your agency is palpable. There’s a whole team of folk back there at HQ whose salaries are paid by this work – it’s no game.
A pitch of a day
And then here it is – the day itself. Bring it on. (Cheerleader pun intended.)
From the restless night spent jostling in your sleep, the sudden burst techno-fear – did you actually charge your laptop? Does Adobe need that update? Can they play video? Do I have the right sodding cable? To the twitchy arrival – small talk and pleasantries out of the way before doing what you came here to do – standing before an (occasional) stony-faced client whose opinion may shatter your entire weeks’ efforts into pieces. That is their right – it’s subjectivity we sell after all isn’t it?
The pitch completes – you try and detect minuscule body language cues and leave instantly starting an episode of something resembling The Prime Minister’s question time, with all the same venom – did I say everything? Shit – you forgot to mention the little detail – might that have made all the difference? What did you look like? Should you have worn that other dress you were arguing with yourself about at 6am? Was I too dressed up? Was I too dressed down? Should I have rolled in full of confidence in jeans and converse? How old exactly is that head of marketing? Are they older than me? Did I sound like I knew what I was talking about? What do they think of me, of us, of the agency? Were they impressed? Disappointed? Bored? Was it all fake enthusiasm?
To be fair if they don’t take your idea then they are idiots – they haven’t felt the sting a good idea if it bit them on the arse. You’ve spent weeks on this, it’s not like you wouldn’t have suggested it if you didn’t bloody well believe it would you?
That’d be the passion. Us bloody creatives.
The adrenaline wanes, the high of ‘we nailed it!’ begins to pass and the comedown begins. Joy.
Your last few days, weeks, even months (poor bugger if that’s you btw) have been building up to this moment – only to be thanked, maybe tossed a crumb of initial feedback, and then get comfortable for the agonising wait to see if it was all worth it. (Anyone who knows me will attest to how impatient I am, so this stage is brutal.)
This time – the awakening as I like to call it – is where you suddenly emerge out of the other side of your pitch-cloud and start to take note of what’s going on in the world around you.
The day feels different – lighter, free almost. You may have the freedom to nip out to get some lunch (pre-lockdown), your day suddenly feels longer and you notice and want to take an interest in the people that have lives around you.
Your other half no longer has to bear the brunt of your pendulum-like moods and the driving torrent of energy around you. Now arriving home at 7pm feels like your skiving and sitting down to eat with your significant other feels like a weekend folly.
By the time the results are in it already feels like weeks or months have passed by – you’ve already gotten stuck into the next problem to solve, a new pitch or a project or are still catching up with all you neglected while pitching. (If you claim you can do it all brilliantly all the time then stop the bull and making the rest of us feel like shit.)
Maybe many of you don’t have this rollercoaster – maybe in years to come it won’t be an issue – the same Creativebrief survey revealed 67% of advertisers would consider hiring an agency even if they refuse to take part in a traditional pitch. (3)
Maybe there’s hope yet. Until then I’m off to buy more dry shampoo.



